2009 Fall Update
Please see SUSTAINABILITY
For Rachel Lindsay's Articles on the Nagarote Reforestation Project
|
|
The good news just got better, even as the bad
news got considerably worse. Read on to learn about the economic
situation in Nicaragua, about its impact on SOSTENICA (pages 1 and
6), and about our programmatic progress despite economic setbacks
(pages 2-5). The U.S. housing boom, which peaked in the middle of
2006, and burst by 2008, triggered an epidemic of foreclosures and
global economic contraction. Yet SOSTENICA, CEPRODEL and Nicaragua
all seemed to have dodged the global economic downturn bullet. Looking
at Page Six, you will see that at the end of 2008, CEPRODEL’s portfolio
at risk had increased only slightly, from 3.51% in 2007 to 4.16%
-- an increase of less than 1%! Since only a very small portion
of a portfolio at risk turns into an actual loan loss, loan repayment
and recovery rates continued to hover within the very healthy 97-98%
range. Then, in the first six months of 2009, arrearages began to
escalate. At the end of June the portfolio at risk greater than
30 days had risen to 7.35%. Two months later, at the end of August,
it was over 12.5%. This represents a significant deterioration of
portfolio quality. What has happened to cause this delayed economic
downturn in Nicaragua? A number of factors are involved.
The strong global economy in 2006 and 2007 created
an increased demand for consumer goods -- including beef -- in Nicaragua.
Many of our rural clients perceived that livestock afforded them
an opportunity to improve their family economy while controlling
for the risks that normally affect agriculture (drought, hurricanes,
volcanic eruptions). Since cows can survive extreme meteorological
events better than corn or beans, cattle looked like a safe bet,
given a strong demand and high prices. So, many borrowers requested
credit to purchase calves to fatten with pasture and grain before
reselling them on the robust Central American market. Suddenly,
early in 2009, the demand for beef in Nicaragua fell, and with it,
the price. Whereas 18 months ago, a cow on the hoof sold for 26
Córdobas a kilo, today the price may be as low as 19. As farmers’
loans came due, they felt reluctant to sell their livestock at such
depressed prices, since it would wipe out most, if not all, of their
anticipated earnings. If only they could hold onto their steers
for a few more months, perhaps the price would recover, and with
it, their earnings. Unfortunately, as the recession lingered and
spread, the demand for beef did not bounce back, nor did the formerly
robust prices.
As soon as a borrower misses a regularly scheduled
payment, his or her loan is marked as “at risk”. After 30 days,
it goes into the category of loans considered seriously in arrears.
While these farmers still had value to back up their loan liabilities,
were they to liquidate their assets, they might actually lose money
after paying off their loan. (Please refer to the table below) With
the number of loans with arrears rising, CEPRODEL has had to triple
its Loan Loss Reserve from $323,598 at the end of 2007 to $975,448
at the end of August 2009. Those funds are subtracted from CEPRODEL’s
net worth. CEPRODEL’s net assets have fallen from $2.46 million
US in 2007 to $2.09 million in 2009. While most U.S. non-profits
would be happy to have over $2 million in net assets, the need to
set aside hundreds of thousands of dollars to cover possible loan
losses is a definite sign of the times.
Adding to the woes of NGO’s operating in the
north and east of Nicaragua is the “No Pay Movement”. On August
12, some Nicaraguan debtors set up road blocks to demand a moratorium
on loan repayment to help ease their financial crisis. While CEPRODEL
does not operate in any of the towns affected, the “No Pay Movement”
created insecurity throughout the Nicaraguan micro-finance industry.
The road blocks came down after four days. Nevertheless, a feeling
of uncertainty lingered. CEPRODEL has continued making new loans
but has reduced its active borrower total from 14,594 at the end
of 2007, to 12,227 by the end of August, 2009 -- a reduction of
16%. Recent loans have gone primarily to known, returning borrowers,
while first time loan applicants will have to await more stable
and prosperous times. Alan Wright, President
|
2009 Spring Update
For a printable 11 x 17 pdf of our 2009 spring Update, please
click here
|
|
2008 Fall Update
October 2008
|
|
Many unlucky Americans who owned
stock in Global Crossings or the Enron Corporation back in 2001
are poorer today by the amount of those holdings. Others holding
shares of Lehman Brothers, Federal National Mortgage Company (FannieMae),
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac), or AIG, the
world’s largest insurance company, at the start of September 2008,
today have portfolios worth significantly less. Many Wall Street
analysts and fund managers considered these stocks to be prudent
investments. Meanwhile, a socially responsible investment alternative
to these bankrupt or financially crippled corporations would have
been to invest in the modest producers and citizens of Nicaragua.
Anyone who has invested in SOSTENICA prior to the volatile times
on Wall Street has seen the value of their SOSTENICA investments
preserved, has earned interest on their investment (although some
choose to accept a reduced interest rate or even no interest at
all), and most importantly, has made it possible for small farm
families and small business people in Nicaragua to obtain credit
to expand and improve their income earning potential.
Most middle-class Americans are accustomed
to having ready access to credit, whether to buy a home, a new car,
or simply to use their credit card to purchase house paint at their
local Home Depot. The recent economic calamities on Wall Street
have made credit more difficult to obtain, as funds have become
scarce and banks more conservative. Welcome to the reality faced
by the average Nicaraguan producer or prospective home owner twelve
months of the year, decade after decade. Imagine for a moment that
you and your family want to buy a new home. The asking price for
the home could be five or six times your annual household income.
In normal times, you could go to your local bank and apply for a
25-year mortgage. Once approved, you could bid on the home of your
dreams. Imagine if you were to own a small business, and wanted
to serve your customers better by acquiring a new technology, some
piece of equipment to make you and your employees more efficient.
Prior to this credit crisis, you would go to your local bank and
apply for a small business line of credit and, once approved, you
would be on your way to more sales. With increased profits you would
pay off your loan, increase your workers’ salaries, and still have
a healthier bottom line. Now imagine that there were NO credit available
to you. Could you buy that house of your dreams with your savings?
Could your business afford that new technology? For many Americans
today, that credit scarcity has become their reality. This is only
one aspect of the difficult economic world in which Nicaraguans
find themselves every day — no credit for home ownership, no credit
for small businesses and no credit for small farm families.
This difficult economic reality is
in part what motivated the founding of SOSTENICA. Since 2001, thousands
of rural Nicaraguans living on small farms, urban Nicaraguans operating
small businesses, and Nicaraguan home owners (24,138 to be exact
as of July, 2008) have benefited from the socially responsible attitudes
of SOSTENICA’s investors. 72% of those loans (17,402) went to women.
In early September, 3,131 Nicaraguans had current lines of credit
or active loans out for their farms, businesses and homes worth
more than three million dollars, thanks to socially responsible
investors through SOSTENICA. 100% of our investor portfolio resides
in Nicaragua, responding to the credit needs of our borrowers. With
just under $2 million literally in the fields and on the streets
of Nicaragua, our loan offices find themselves with an additional
requests for credit totaling over $3 million, loan requests which
we are unable to satisfy for lack of additional investment.
Perhaps, with our elected officials
restructuring investment banks, insurance and mortgage companies,
this would be an ideal time for each of us to reevaluate our investments,
to ask ourselves if our holdings are secure. More importantly, we
might ask ourselves whether our current investments accurately reflect
our values and beliefs. Ask yourself if SOSTENICAmight not be just
the right investment to balance a portfolio in need of compassion
and loving kindness. —Alan Wright, Ph.D. SOSTENICA President
|
|
SOSTENICA and CEPRODEL take pride
in our partnership. Since our earliest experiments with micro-credit
in Nicaragua back in 1993, CEPRODEL and SOSTENICA have been dedicated
partners, serving low income families in need of credit and technical
assistance. The generous family of people collaborating on this
valuable project from its inception has included like minded participants,
both individuals and institutions, including churches, orders of
Catholic nuns, forprofit as well as not-for-profit organizations.
Recently SOSTENICA has expanded this family to include programmatic
alliances, helping us to advance our mission. The following brief
essays introduce to SOSTENICA’s readers six of our most valuable
ongoing partnerships.
No listing of SOSTENICA’s strategic
alliances would be complete without honoring a group of “ordinary
men seeking to lead extraordinary lives.” They are the Men’s
Team of Connecticut. Over the past few years these men have
made SOSTENICA one of their principal social projects. They have
raised money, sought investors, sponsored public events, and even
produced a documentary about the work of SOSTENICA. We salute these
extraordinary men and thank them for their efforts to achieve greater
social justice in Nicaragua.
One long term partnership in the
effort to bring sustainability to Nicaragua has been between SOSTENICA
and the Norwalk/Nagarote Sister City Project (www.sistercityproject.org).
Norwalk/Nagarote seeks to promote sustainable community development
between the people of Nagarote, Nicaragua and the Greater Norwalk
Area of Connecticut. The Sister City Project focuses on youth in
Nagarote with scholarships for 69 youngsters from first grade through
university, support of a preschool, and an after school Youth Project
designed to deal with the growing problem of gangs, drugs and violence.
Currently, there are 150 teens actively involved in the program.
The program has three major components: after school classes; Community
Education workshops; and community service including urban reforestation.
Instead of joining gangs, experimenting with drugs and getting into
trouble, the teens are planting trees, winning soccer games, learning
photography and setting an example for others in the community.
They have grown more than 10,000 trees from seed and distributed
them to residents in the community who agree to care for them. Not
only is Norwalk/Nagarote an investor with SOSTENICA, it hopes to
join with SOSTENICA and CEPRODEL in Nagarote to provide teens with
training in managing a small business. Because of a poor economy
and high unemployment, the informal sector is the best source of
jobs, but it takes “know how” to start a business successfully.
SOSTENICA is currently negotiating with CEPRODEL and the Norwalk/Nagarote
Sister City Project to have Nagarote youth grow trees to distribute
to farmer/borrowers. They have already distributed 1,000 trees grown
in the Youth Project nursery.
Rammed Earth Works’ founders,
David Easton and Cynthia Wright, first collaborated with projects
in Nicaragua in 1992, assisting the residents of the Guadalupe barrio
of León to construct the Los Carlitos pre-school out of rammed earth
(www.rammedearthworks.com).
More recently Rammed Earth Works has collaborated with the construction
of Las Bellotas, an environmental education center, this time in
rammed earth and bamboo at Las Cañadas in Mexico. David and Cynthia
have become strategic partners, consulting with SOSTENICA about
how to construct low cost housing using locally available green
building materials.
Some years ago UNAN/León (the
oldest campus of the Autonomous National University of Nicaragua)
created a fiveyear engineering degree program in Tropical Agro-Ecology
(www.unanleon.edu.ni).
This is the only program of its type in the country. University
students are trained as agronomists without having to rely on conventional
“green revolution” technologies, which have been chemical dependent.
Rather than using chemical fertilizers, pesticides and herbicides,
students learn to grow crops and livestock organically using integrated
pest management and permaculture principles. Dr. Tito Antón, one
of the founders of the Agro-Ecology masters program at UNAN, has
agreed to cooperate with SOSTENICA in offering technical assistance
to farmer borrowers.
Hal Taussig and Elizabeth Killough
of the Untours Foundation (www.untoursfoundation.org)
have created a Charitable Remainder Trust to support working families
of Nicaragua through SOSTENICA. Supporters of Untours are being
asked to make a tax deductible donation to Untours. Those funds
will be invested with SOSTENICA, and loaned to families in Nicaragua,
with any interest earned on the investment being paid to the original
donor for the remainder of their lives. Nine years ago the late
Paul Newman awarded Taussig and Untours with his prestigious “Most
Generous Company in America” award. Now that generosity is being
directed towards Nicaragua.
Las Cañadas, an ecological
farming cooperative in Huatusco, Mexico founded by Ricardo Romero
(www.bosquedeniebla.com.mx),
offers training in sustainable agriculture and organic livestock
production. Las Cañadas and SOSTENICA have teamed up to train CEPRODEL
field staff, who, in turn, serves SOSTENICA borrowers. This November,
representatives from UNAN/León, SOSTENICA and CEPRODEL will attend
a week-long training in Agroecology and Biointensive agriculture
at Las Cañadas.
Friends of the Mexican Cloudforest,
founded by Paula Kline, is affiliated with Las Cañadas, and has
planted more than 20,000 native hardwood trees in the past two years
in an attempt to restore over 200 acres of local cloud forest habitat.
In addition, Friends is designing and planting 2.4 acres as an experimental
edible forest, to provide perennial fruit and vegetable crops year
round. A workshop in Food Forest Gardening, led by author Eric Toensmeier
is being scheduled for February, 2009. Lessons learned will become
part of the SOSTENICA mission and message. (http://www.friendsofthecloudforest.org)
|
 |
Doña Aida de la Cruz Carrillo is one
of SOSTENICA’s sweetest borrowers. For the past ten years, she has
collected, processed and sold honey. She has been recognized by her
peers for her skill and ingenuity, having been named as a member of
the Comisión Nacional de Apicultores (National Commission of Beekeepers).
Aida has represented the Commission innumerous training events, allowing
her to master the many elements of honey production and sales, and
sharing her knowledge with her colleagues. |
|
As a leader and spokesperson in the
Nicaraguan beekeepers association, she believes that honey represents
a viable outlet for the national economy, due to its potential both
in terms of demand from the European market, and because the production
of honey contributes to the health of the natural environment.
With the help of SOSTENICA/CEPRODEL,
she has increased her productive capacity. She currently has 82
hives, processes her own honey and does her own marketing. She bottles
both in glass and in plastic, under her trademark The Sigh of the
Honeybees (“Miel de abejas el suspiro”). She proudly produces a
product that guarantees both quality and hygiene. She is licensed
and registered nationally.
To date, Doña Aida has received two
loans from SOSTENICA totaling $5,000. Her most recent loan was used
to purchase equipment to process her honey. Her net worth has grown
by 25% in the last twelve months, from $9,786 to $12,250, permitting
her to realize many of her aspirations and life goals.
|
| “The concept of land ownership must
be overthrown. We must begin to see ourselves not as owners with rights
and privileges, but rather, as stewards, with responsibilities and
opportunities. If we pay close attention to the messages being transmitted
to us through the trees, birds and insects, through the microorganisms
in the soil and the coded messages in our dreams, we might just escape
from the confusion which has become so typical of contemporary life.
We might learn again how to live in right relation with creation.”
—Alan Wright |
|
As of September 2008 SosteNica has a portfolio at work of $1,907,250.
The source of these funds:
$ 713,550 by 83 individual investors
$1,193,700 by 20 institutional investors
Carlos Casares, CEPRODEL’S Director of Credit, estimates that it
would take an additional $3,000,000 to meet the needs of small business
persons and farm families in the areas served by
|
From January 2001 through July 2008
From the Leon Offices of CEPRODEL
(The numbers were incorrect in the Print Version of the Update)
| Number of Loans Made |
24,138 |
| Amount Loaned |
$13,203,198 |
| Women |
|
| Number |
17,402 |
| Amount |
$6,862,768 |
| Men |
|
| Number |
6,673 |
| Amount |
$6,154,427 |
| Cooperatives |
|
| Number |
63 |
| Amount |
$186,003 |
| Urban |
|
| Number |
19,824 |
| Amount |
$7,320,421 |
| Rural |
|
| Number |
4,314 |
| Amount |
$5,882,777 |
|
______________________________________________________________________________________________
|